Infrastructure tools to support an effective radiation oncology learning health system

VHDL (VHSIC Hardware Description Language) is a hardware description language that can model the behavior and structure of digital systems at multiple levels of abstraction, ranging from the system level down to that of logic gates, for design entry, documentation, and verification purposes. The language was developed for the US military VHSIC program in the 1980s, and has been standardized by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) as IEEE Std 1076; the latest version of which is IEEE Std 1076-2019. To model analog and mixed-signal systems, an IEEE-standardized HDL based on VHDL called VHDL-AMS (officially IEEE 1076.1) has been developed.

In 1983, VHDL was originally developed at the behest of the U.S. Department of Defense in order to document the behavior of the ASICs that supplier companies were including in equipment. The standard MIL-STD-454N^[2] in Requirement 64 in section 4.5.1 "ASIC documentation in VHDL" explicitly requires documentation of "Microelectronic Devices" in VHDL.

The idea of being able to simulate the ASICs from the information in this documentation was so obviously attractive that logic simulators were developed that could read the VHDL files. The next step was the development of logic synthesis tools that read the VHDL and output a definition of the physical implementation of the circuit.

Due to the Department of Defense requiring as much of the syntax as possible to be based on Ada, in order to avoid re-inventing concepts that had already been thoroughly tested in the development of Ada,^{[citation needed]} VHDL borrows heavily from the Ada programming language in both concept and syntax.

The initial version of VHDL, designed to IEEE standard IEEE 1076-1987,^[3] included a wide range of data types, including numerical (integer and real), logical (bit and Boolean), character and time, plus arrays of bit called bit_vector and of character called string.

A problem not solved by this edition, however, was "multi-valued logic", where a signal's drive strength (none, weak or strong) and unknown values are also considered. This required IEEE standard 1164, which defined the 9-value logic types: scalar std_logic and its vector version std_logic_vector. Being a resolved subtype of its std_Ulogic parent type, std_logic-typed signals allow multiple driving for modeling bus structures, whereby the connected resolution function handles conflicting assignments adequately.

The updated IEEE 1076, in 1993, made the syntax more consistent, allowed more flexibility in naming, extended the character type to allow ISO-8859-1 printable characters, added the xnor operator, etc.^[specify]

Minor changes in the standard (2000 and 2002) added the idea of protected types (similar to the concept of class in C++) and removed some restrictions from port mapping rules.

In addition to IEEE standard 1164, several child standards were introduced to extend functionality of the language. IEEE standard 1076.2 added better handling of real and complex data types. IEEE standard 1076.3 introduced signed and unsigned types to facilitate arithmetical operations on vectors. IEEE standard 1076.1 (known as VHDL-AMS) provided analog and mixed-signal circuit design extensions.

Some other standards support wider use of VHDL, notably VITAL (VHDL Initiative Towards ASIC Libraries) and microwave circuit design extensions.

In June 2006, the VHDL Technical Committee of Accellera (delegated by IEEE to work on the next update of the standard) approved so-called Draft 3.0 of VHDL-2006. While maintaining full compatibility with older versions, this proposed standard provides numerous extensions that make writing and managing VHDL code easier. Key changes include incorporation of child standards (1164, 1076.2, 1076.3) into the main 1076 standard, an extended set of operators, more flexible syntax of case and generate statements, incorporation of VHPI (VHDL Procedural Interface) (interface to C/C++ languages) and a subset of PSL (Property Specification Language). These changes should improve quality of synthesizable VHDL code, make testbenches more flexible, and allow wider use of VHDL for system-level descriptions.

In February 2008, Accellera approved VHDL 4.0, also informally known as VHDL 2008, which addressed more than 90 issues discovered during the trial period for version 3.0 and includes enhanced generic types. In 2008, Accellera released VHDL 4.0 to the IEEE for balloting for inclusion in IEEE 1076-2008. The VHDL standard IEEE 1076-2008^[4] was published in January 2009.

The IEEE Standard 1076 defines the VHSIC Hardware Description Language, or VHDL. It was originally developed under contract F33615-83-C-1003 from the United States Air Force awarded in 1983 to a team of Intermetrics, Inc. as language experts and prime contractor, Texas Instruments as chip design experts and IBM as computer-system design experts. The language has undergone numerous revisions and has a variety of sub-standards associated with it that augment or extend it in important ways.

1076 was and continues to be a milestone in the design of electronic systems.^[5]

• IEEE 1076-1987^[3] First standardized revision of ver 7.2 of the language from the United States Air Force.
• IEEE 1076-1993^[6] (also published with ISBN 1-55937-376-8). Significant improvements resulting from several years of feedback. Probably the most widely used version with the greatest vendor tool support.
• IEEE 1076-2000.^[7] Minor revision. Introduces the use of protected types.
• IEEE 1076-2002.^[8] Minor revision of 1076-2000. Rules with regard to buffer ports are relaxed.
  • IEC 61691-1-1:2004.^[9] IEC adoption of IEEE 1076-2002.
• IEEE 1076c-2007.^[10] Introduced VHPI, the VHDL procedural interface, which provides software with the means to access the VHDL model. The VHDL language required minor modifications to accommodate the VHPI.
• IEEE 1076-2008 (previously referred to as 1076-200x). Major revision released on 2009-01-26. Among other changes, this standard incorporates a basic subset of PSL, allows for generics on packages and subprograms and introduces the use of external names.
  • IEC 61691-1-1:2011.^[11] IEC adoption of IEEE 1076-2008.
• IEEE 1076-2019. Major revision.

• IEEE 1076.1 VHDL Analog and Mixed-Signal (VHDL-AMS)
• IEEE 1076.1.1 VHDL-AMS Standard Packages (stdpkgs)
• IEEE 1076.2 VHDL Math Package
• IEEE 1076.3 VHDL Synthesis Package (vhdlsynth) (numeric std)
• IEEE 1076.3 VHDL Synthesis Package – Floating Point (fphdl)
• IEEE 1076.4 Timing (VHDL Initiative Towards ASIC Libraries: vital)
• IEEE 1076.6 VHDL Synthesis Interoperability (withdrawn in 2010)^[12]
• IEEE 1164 VHDL Multivalue Logic (std_logic_1164) Packages

VHDL is generally used to write text models that describe a logic circuit. Such a model is processed by a synthesis program, only if it is part of the logic design. A simulation program is used to test the logic design using simulation models to represent the logic circuits that interface to the design. This collection of simulation models is commonly called a testbench.

A VHDL simulator is typically an event-driven simulator.^[13] This means that each transaction is added to an event queue for a specific scheduled time. E.g. if a signal assignment should occur after 1 nanosecond, the event is added to the queue for time +1ns. Zero delay is also allowed, but still needs to be scheduled: for these cases delta delay is used, which represent an infinitely small time step. The simulation alters between two modes: statement execution, where triggered statements are evaluated, and event processing, where events in the queue are processed.

VHDL has constructs to handle the parallelism inherent in hardware designs, but these constructs (processes) differ in syntax from the parallel constructs in Ada (tasks). Like Ada, VHDL is strongly typed and is not case sensitive. In order to directly represent operations which are common in hardware, there are many features of VHDL which are not found in Ada, such as an extended set of Boolean operators including nand and nor.

VHDL has file input and output capabilities, and can be used as a general-purpose language for text processing, but files are more commonly used by a simulation testbench for stimulus or verification data. There are some VHDL compilers which build executable binaries. In this case, it might be possible to use VHDL to write a testbench to verify the functionality of the design using files on the host computer to define stimuli, to interact with the user, and to compare results with those expected. However, most designers leave this job to the simulator.

It is relatively easy for an inexperienced developer to produce code that simulates successfully but that cannot be synthesized into a real device, or is too large to be practical. One particular pitfall is the accidental production of transparent latches rather than D-type flip-flops as storage elements.^[14]

One can design hardware in a VHDL IDE (for FPGA implementation such as Xilinx ISE, Altera Quartus, Synopsys Synplify or Mentor Graphics HDL Designer) to produce the RTL schematic of the desired circuit. After that, the generated schematic can be verified using simulation software which shows the waveforms of inputs and outputs of the circuit after generating the appropriate testbench. To generate an appropriate testbench for a particular circuit or VHDL code, the inputs have to be defined correctly. For example, for clock input, a loop process or an iterative statement is required.^[15]

A final point is that when a VHDL model is translated into the "gates and wires" that are mapped onto a programmable logic device such as a CPLD or FPGA, then it is the actual hardware being configured, rather than the VHDL code being "executed" as if on some form of a processor chip.

The key advantage of VHDL, when used for systems design, is that it allows the behavior of the required system to be described (modeled) and verified (simulated) before synthesis tools translate the design into real hardware (gates and wires).

Another benefit is that VHDL allows the description of a concurrent system. VHDL is a dataflow language in which every statement is considered for execution simultaneously, unlike procedural computing languages such as BASIC, C, and assembly code, where a sequence of statements is run sequentially one instruction at a time.

A VHDL project is multipurpose. Being created once, a calculation block can be used in many other projects. However, many formational and functional block parameters can be tuned (capacity parameters, memory size, element base, block composition and interconnection structure).

A VHDL project is portable. Being created for one element base, a computing device project can be ported on another element base, for example VLSI with various technologies.

A big advantage of VHDL compared to original Verilog is that VHDL has a full type system. Designers can use the type system to write much more structured code (especially by declaring record types).^[16]

In VHDL, a design consists at a minimum of an entity which describes the interface and an architecture which contains the actual implementation. In addition, most designs import library modules. Some designs also contain multiple architectures and configurations.

A simple AND gate in VHDL would look something like

-- (this is a VHDL comment)
/*
    this is a block comment (VHDL-2008)
*/
-- import std_logic from the IEEE library
library IEEE;
use IEEE.std_logic_1164.all;

-- this is the entity
entity ANDGATE is
  port ( 
    I1 : in std_logic;
    I2 : in std_logic;
    O  : out std_logic);
end entity ANDGATE;

-- this is the architecture
architecture RTL of ANDGATE is
begin
  O <= I1 and I2;
end architecture RTL;

(Notice that RTL stands for Register transfer level design.) While the example above may seem verbose to HDL beginners, many parts are either optional or need to be written only once. Generally simple functions like this are part of a larger behavioral module, instead of having a separate module for something so simple. In addition, use of elements such as the std_logic type might at first seem to be an overkill. One could easily use the built-in bit type and avoid the library import in the beginning. However, using a form of many-valued logic, specifically 9-valued logic (U,X,0,1,Z,W,H,L,-), instead of simple bits (0,1) offers a very powerful simulation and debugging tool to the designer which currently does not exist in any other HDL.

In the examples that follow, you will see that VHDL code can be written in a very compact form. However, more experienced designers usually avoid these compact forms and use a more verbose coding style for the sake of readability and maintainability.

VHDL is frequently used for two different goals: simulation of electronic designs and synthesis of such designs. Synthesis is a process where a VHDL is compiled and mapped into an implementation technology such as an FPGA or an ASIC.

Not all constructs in VHDL are suitable for synthesis. For example, most constructs that explicitly deal with timing such as wait for 10 ns; are not synthesizable despite being valid for simulation. While different synthesis tools have different capabilities, there exists a common synthesizable subset of VHDL that defines what language constructs and idioms map into common hardware for many synthesis tools. IEEE 1076.6 defines a subset of the language that is considered the official synthesis subset. It is generally considered a "best practice" to write very idiomatic code for synthesis as results can be incorrect or suboptimal for non-standard constructs.

The multiplexer, or 'MUX' as it is usually called, is a simple construct very common in hardware design. The example below demonstrates a simple two to one MUX, with inputs A and B, selector S and output X. Note that there are many other ways to express the same MUX in VHDL.^[17]

X <= A when S = '1' else B;

A more complex example of a MUX with 4x3 inputs and a 2-bit selector:

library IEEE;
use IEEE.std_logic_1164.all;
entity mux4 is
  port(
    a1      : in  std_logic_vector(2 downto 0);
    a2      : in  std_logic_vector(2 downto 0);
    a3      : in  std_logic_vector(2 downto 0);
    a4      : in  std_logic_vector(2 downto 0);
    sel     : in  std_logic_vector(1 downto 0);
    b       : out std_logic_vector(2 downto 0)
  );
end mux4;
architecture rtl of mux4 is
  -- declarative part: empty
begin
  p_mux : process(a1,a2,a3,a4,sel)
  begin
    case sel is
      when "00" => b <= a1 ;
      when "01" => b <= a2 ;
      when "10" => b <= a3 ;
      when others => b <= a4 ;
    end case;
  end process p_mux;
end rtl;

A transparent latch is basically one bit of memory which is updated when an enable signal is raised. Again, there are many other ways this can be expressed in VHDL.

-- latch template 1:
Q <= D when Enable = '1' else Q;

-- latch template 2:
process(all)
begin
    Q <= D when(Enable);
end process;

The D-type flip-flop samples an incoming signal at the rising (or falling) edge of a clock. This example has an asynchronous, active-high reset, and samples at the rising clock edge.

DFF : process(all) is
begin
  if RST then
    Q <= '0';
  elsif rising_edge(CLK) then
    Q <= D;
  end if;
end process DFF;

Another common way to write edge-triggered behavior in VHDL is with the 'event' signal attribute. A single apostrophe has to be written between the signal name and the name of the attribute.

DFF : process(RST, CLK) is
begin
  if RST then
    Q <= '0';
  elsif CLK'event and CLK = '1' then
    Q <= D;
  end if;
end process DFF;

VHDL also lends itself to "one-liners" such as

DFF : Q <= '0' when RST = '1' else D when rising_edge(clk);

or

DFF : process(all) is 
begin
  if rising_edge(CLK) then
    Q <= D;
  end if;
  if RST then
    Q <= '0';
  end if;
end process DFF;

or:

Library IEEE;
USE IEEE.Std_logic_1164.all;

entity RisingEdge_DFlipFlop_SyncReset is
  port(
    Q          :   out std_logic;    
    Clk        : in    std_logic;  
    sync_reset : in    std_logic;  
    D          : in    std_logic    
  );
end RisingEdge_DFlipFlop_SyncReset;

architecture Behavioral of RisingEdge_DFlipFlop_SyncReset is
begin
  process(Clk)
  begin 
    if (rising_edge(Clk)) then
      if (sync_reset='1') then 
        Q <= '0';
      else 
        Q <= D; 
      end if;
    end if;       
  end process;  
end Behavioral;

Which can be useful if not all signals (registers) driven by this process should be reset.

The following example is an up-counter with asynchronous reset, parallel load and configurable width. It demonstrates the use of the 'unsigned' type, type conversions between 'unsigned' and 'std_logic_vector' and VHDL generics. The generics are very close to arguments or templates in other traditional programming languages like C++. The example is in VHDL 2008 language.

library IEEE;
use IEEE.std_logic_1164.all;
use IEEE.numeric_std.all;    -- for the unsigned type

entity COUNTER is
  generic (
    WIDTH : in natural := 32);
  port (
    RST   : in std_logic;
    CLK   : in std_logic;
    LOAD  : in std_logic;
    DATA  : in std_logic_vector(WIDTH-1 downto 0);
    Q     : out std_logic_vector(WIDTH-1 downto 0));
end entity COUNTER;

architecture RTL of COUNTER is

begin

  process(all) is
  begin
    if RST then
      Q <= (others => '0');
    elsif rising_edge(CLK) then
      if LOAD='1' then
        Q <= DATA;
      else
        Q <= std_logic_vector(unsigned(Q) + 1);
      end if;
    end if;
  end process;

end architecture RTL;

More complex counters may add if/then/else statements within the rising_edge(CLK) elsif to add other functions, such as count enables, stopping or rolling over at some count value, generating output signals like terminal count signals, etc. Care must be taken with the ordering and nesting of such controls if used together, in order to produce the desired priorities and minimize the number of logic levels needed.

A large subset of VHDL cannot be translated into hardware. This subset is known as the non-synthesizable or the simulation-only subset of VHDL and can only be used for prototyping, simulation and debugging. For example, the following code will generate a clock with a frequency of 50 MHz. It can, for example, be used to drive a clock input in a design during simulation. It is, however, a simulation-only construct and cannot be implemented in hardware. In actual hardware, the clock is generated externally; it can be scaled down internally by user logic or dedicated hardware.

process
begin
  CLK <= '1'; wait for 10 NS;
  CLK <= '0'; wait for 10 NS;
end process;

The simulation-only constructs can be used to build complex waveforms in very short time. Such waveform can be used, for example, as test vectors for a complex design or as a prototype of some synthesizer logic that will be implemented in the future.

process
begin
  wait until START = '1'; -- wait until START is high
  
  for i in 1 to 10 loop -- then wait for a few clock periods...
    wait until rising_edge(CLK);
  end loop;

  for i in 1 to 10 loop 	-- write numbers 1 to 10 to DATA, 1 every cycle
    DATA <= to_unsigned(i, 8);
    wait until rising_edge(CLK);
  end loop;

  -- wait until the output changes
  wait on RESULT;
  
  -- now raise ACK for clock period
  ACK <= '1';
  wait until rising_edge(CLK);
  ACK <= '0';

  -- and so on...
end process;

library ieee;
use ieee.std_logic_1164.all;

entity bfm is end entity;
architecture beh of bfm is
    signal en   :std_logic;
begin
    -- insert implementation here
end architecture;

//------------------------------------------
library ieee;
use ieee.std_logic_1164.all;

entity test1 is end entity;
architecture beh of test1 is
begin

    ibfm: entity work.bfm;
	
    -- The testbench process
    process
      alias probe_en   is <<signal .test1.ibfm.en :std_logic>>;
    begin
        probe_en   <= '1';
        wait for 100 ns;
        probe_en   <= '0';		
        wait for 100 ns;
        probe_en   <= '1';		
        wait for 100 ns;        
        std.env.stop(0);
    end process;
	
end architecture;

Also referred as standard packages.

The IEEE Standard Package includes the following:^[18]

• numeric_std
• std_logic_1164
  • std_logic_arith
  • std_logic_unsigned
  • std_logic_signed
  • std_logic_misc

Commercial:

• Aldec Active-HDL
• Cadence Incisive
• Mentor Graphics ModelSim
• Mentor Graphics Questa Advanced Simulator
• Synopsys VCS-MX^[19]
• Xilinx Vivado Design Suite (features the Vivado Simulator)

Other:

• EDA Playground - Free web browser-based VHDL IDE (uses Synopsys VCS, Cadence Incisive, Aldec Riviera-PRO and GHDL for VHDL simulation)
• GHDL is an open source^[20] VHDL compiler that can execute VHDL programs. GHDL on GitHub
• boot by freerangefactory.org is a VHDL compiler and simulator based on GHDL and GTKWave
• VHDL Simili by Symphony EDA is a free commercial VHDL simulator.
• nvc by Nick Gasson is an open source VHDL compiler and simulator^[21][22]
• freehdl by Edwin Naroska was an open source VHDL simulator, abandoned since 2001.^[23]

Notes

• Peter J. Ashenden, "The Designer's Guide to VHDL, Third Edition (Systems on Silicon)", 2008, ISBN 0-1208-8785-1. (The VHDL reference book written by one of the lead developers of the language)
• Bryan Mealy, Fabrizio Tappero (February 2012). [1]. The no-frills guide to writing powerful VHDL code for your digital implementations. Archived from the original Free Range VHDL on 2015-02-13.
• Johan Sandstrom (October 1995). "Comparing Verilog to VHDL Syntactically and Semantically". Integrated System Design. EE Times. — Sandstrom presents a table relating VHDL constructs to Verilog constructs.
• Qualis Design Corporation (2000-07-20). "VHDL quick reference card" (PDF). 1.1. Qualis Design Corporation. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2003-12-10. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
• Qualis Design Corporation (2000-07-20). "1164 packages quick reference card" (PDF). 1.0. Qualis Design Corporation. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2016-03-14. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
• Janick Bergeron, "Writing Testbenches: Functional Verification of HDL Models", 2000, ISBN 0-7923-7766-4. (The HDL Testbench Bible)

• Official website
• VHDL Analysis and Standardization Group (VASG)