FAIR and interactive data graphics from a scientific knowledge graph

Posted on June 17, 2024 By LabLynx Journal articles

This article is about the persons described as Jesus' brothers. For the Catholic religious congregation, see Little Brothers of Jesus.
"Adelphoi," the Greek word for "siblings" or specifically "brothers," redirects here. For siblings, including brothers, in general, see Sibling and Brother.
Part of a series on
Jewish Christianity
"The Sermon on the Mount" by Carl Bloch (1834–1890)
Figures
Ancient groups
Recent groups
Pejoratives
Adversity
Writings
New Testament
Jewish–Christian gospels
Other
Issues

The brothers of Jesus or the adelphoi (Ancient Greek: ἀδελφοί, romanized: adelphoí, lit. 'of the same womb, brothers')[1][a] are named in the New Testament as James, Joses (a form of Joseph), Simon, Jude,[2] and unnamed sisters are mentioned in Mark and Matthew.[3] They may have been: (1) sons of Mary, the mother of Jesus, and Joseph; (2) sons of Joseph by a former marriage; or (3) sons of Mary of Clopas, named in Mark 15:40 as the "mother of James and Joses", who has been identified as either the sister of Mary, the mother of Jesus, or a sister-in-law to Joseph. [4][b]

Those who uphold the perpetual virginity of Mary reject the idea of biological brethren and maintain that the brothers and sisters were either cousins of Jesus (option 3, the position of the Catholic Church) or children of Joseph from a previous marriage (option 2, the Eastern Orthodox Churches).[4] Some Lutheran Churches have accepted both option 2 and option 3 as being valid explanations for the doctrine of the perpetual virginity of Mary.[5][6]

Etymology

According to context, the Greek plural noun ἀδελφοί (adelphoi), from a- ('same') and delphys ('womb'),[1] may mean physical brothers, physical brothers and sisters, figurative brothers, or figurative brothers and sisters.[7] Adelphoi sometimes means more than a blood brother, e.g., Gen 29:12; Rom 9:3 (kinsman); Matt 5:22–3 (neighbor); Mark 6:17–8 (step-brother). In such instances the context must determine the meaning.[8] Adelphoi is distinct from anepsios, meaning cousin, nephew, niece, and this word is never used to describe James and the other siblings of Jesus.[9] The word "anepsios" is only employed once in the entire New Testament, being used in Paul's Epistle to the Colossians. Although neither Hebrew nor Aramaic had a word for "cousin", both customarily spoke of a cousin as a "son of an uncle" (Heb. ben dod; Aram. bar dad)[8] and the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Old Testament, never translates either expression as "brother" or "sister".[8]

The Vulgate renders with the Latin word frater (e.g. Mark 6:3), which, even in classical Latin, can also mean "maternal cousin" or "paternal cousin".[10]

Adelphoi (brethren) of Jesus

James the Just, 16th-century Russian icon

Mark 6:3 names James, Joses, Judas (conventionally known in English as Jude) and Simon as the brothers of Jesus, and Matthew 13:55, which probably used Mark as its source, gives the same names in different order, James, Joseph, Simon and Judas.[11] "Joseph" is simply the longer form of "Joses", and so it appears that James was the eldest and Joses/Joseph the next, but as Matthew has reversed the order of the last two it is uncertain who was the youngest.[12] Unnamed sisters are mentioned in Mark 6:3 and Matthew 13:56 and may be implied in Mark 3:35 and Matthew 12:46, but their number is unknown.[3]

The gospels indicate a rift between Jesus and his brothers in the early part of his ministry (see Mark 3:31-35 and the parallel passages in Matthew 12:46-50 and Luke 8:19-21), and they never appear among his followers during his lifetime.[13] John has Jesus' brothers advising him to go to Judea despite being aware that his life would be in danger, and they are absent from his burial, which should have been their responsibility,[14] but they do appear in Acts 1:14 with the Eleven (i.e., the remaining disciples after the betrayal by Judas Iscariot): "These all (the Eleven) were persevering in prayer along with the women, with Mary the mother of Jesus, and with his brothers."[14]

In 1 Corinthians 15:3–7 Paul lists a "James" among those to whom the risen Christ had appeared,[15] and most scholars agree that this refers to James the brother of Jesus.[16] The 2nd century historian Hegesippus (c.110 – 180 AD) reports that James the brother of Jesus came to be known as James the Just,[17] and Eusebius of Caesarea (died 339) says that he spent so much of his life in prayer that his knees became "like the knees of a camel."[18] According to Clement of Alexandria, reported by Eusebius, he was chosen as bishop of Jerusalem,[19] and from the time when Peter left Jerusalem after Herod's attempt to kill him (Acts 12) he appears as the principal authority in the Jerusalem church, presiding at the Council of Jerusalem recorded in Acts 15.[19] In Galatians 1:19 Paul tells how he went to Jerusalem a few years after his conversion and met Cephas (Peter) but no other apostles, only "James, the brother of the Lord";[20] Paul's Greek leaves it unclear whether he includes, or does not include, James among the apostles.[21] He goes on to describe a second visit fourteen years later when he met the "pillars of the Church", James and Peter and John; James is mentioned first and seems to be the primary leader among these three.[15] In chapter 2 he describes how he and Peter were later in Antioch and in the habit of dining with gentile Christians in breach of Jewish torah, until "certain people from James" came and Peter withdrew, "fearing those who belong to the circumcision."[22] The 1st century historian Josephus tells how he was martyred by the Jews in 62 CE on charges of breaking the Jewish Law.[18]

Paul records in 1 Corinthians that the other brothers of Jesus (that is, other than James, who is portrayed as rooted in Jerusalem) travelled as evangelists, and that they were married ("Do we not have the right to be accompanied by a believing wife, as do the other apostles and the brothers of the Lord and Cephas (Peter)?" - 1 Corinthians 9:5).[23] The 3rd century Apostolic Father Eusebius left a list of 12 bishops of the early church, of whom two, Joseph/Joses and Jude, may be the brothers of Jesus.[24] The number of sisters and their names are not specified in the New Testament, but the apocryphal 3rd century Gospel of Philip mentions a Mary, and Salome, who appears in the late 2nd century Gospel of James, is arguably the other sister.[25]

The author of the epistle of James introduces himself as "James, a servant of God and of the Lord Jesus Christ".[26] He does not identify himself as the brother of Jesus or an apostle or a leader of the church in any way,[18] but one recent study characterises this letter as "the most Jewish text in the New Testament".[27] The epistle of Jude identifies its author as "Jude...the brother of James", but today there is widespread, although not unanimous, support for the view that it was composed in the early part of the 2nd century by an unknown author borrowing the name of the brother of Jesus.[28] Hegesippus mentions a Simon or Simeon (the names are equivalent) who became leader of the Jerusalem church after the death of James, but makes this Simon a son of Clopas, the brother of Joseph.[29]

Of the "brothers," however, no direct relationship to Mary or Joseph is ever indicated. Only Jesus is referred to as "son of Mary," "the son of Mary," or "son of Joseph." Only Jesus is the subject of the Old Testament messianic prophecies and only of him is the genealogy proposed.[30]

Relationship to Jesus

Martyrdom of St. Simeon (Menologion of Basil II, 10th century)

The 19th century scholar J.B. Lightfoot identified three possible positions on the relationship to Jesus of those called his brothers and sisters by reference to their 4th century advocates, namely the Helvidian (after Helvidius, who wrote c. 380), the Epiphanian (after Epiphanius of Salamis, 315-403), and the Hieronymian (after Jerome, 349-419/20).[31] A fourth position, not mentioned by Lightfoot, is that the adelphoi were full-blooded brothers and sisters of Jesus.[31]

Full blood-brothers and sisters of Jesus

This position rejects the virgin birth of Jesus and argues his brothers and sisters were full siblings. Main proponents of this belief were the Ebionites, a 2nd century Jewish Christian sect, who rejected both the incarnation and divinity of Jesus.[31]

Half-brothers and sisters of Jesus (Helvidian view)

The view of Helvidius was that the adelphoi were half siblings of Jesus born to Mary and Joseph after the firstborn Jesus.[32] This is the most common Protestant position.[32] The following hypothetical family tree is from Jesus and His World book written by John J Rousseau and Rami Arav: [33][34]

MaryJosephClopasanother Mary
JesusJames
d. 62		JosesSimonsistersisterJudeSimeon
successor to James as head
of the Jerusalem Church
d. 106
?
?
Bishop Judah Kyriakos
fl. c. 148–49

Stepbrothers of Jesus (Epiphanian view)

The Epiphanian view, named after its main proponent, the fourth-century bishop Epiphanius, and championed by the third century theologian Origen and fourth-century bishop Eusebius, the “brothers” and “sisters” mentioned in the New Testament are sons of Joseph from a previous marriage, and hence stepbrothers of Jesus; this is still the official position of the Eastern Orthodox churches.[35]

MaryJosephearlier wife
JesusJamesJosesSimonJude

Cousins of Jesus (Hieronymian view)

The Hieronymian view was put forward in the 4th century by Jerome, who argued that not only Mary, but Joseph too, had been a life-long virgin.[36] Apparently voicing the general opinion of the Church, he held that the "brothers of Jesus" were the sons of Mary the "mother of James and Joses" mentioned in Mark 15:40, whom he identified with the wife of Clopas and sister of Mary, the mother of Jesus mentioned in John 19:25.[37] The Catholic Church continues to teach that the adelphoi were cousins of Jesus.[38] The following family tree is from Richard Bauckham, "Jude and the Relatives of James":[39]

AnneJoachim
JosephMaryanother MaryClopas
JesusJames the LessJosesSimonJude

Jerome's argument produces the unlikely result of two sisters both named Mary.[39] A modern variant eliminates this by identifying Clopas as the brother of Joseph, thereby making the two Marys sisters-in-law; in this version Jesus' cousin Simon is identified with Symeon the second leader of the church in Jerusalem.[39][40] The following family tree is from Richard Bauckham, "Jude and the Relatives of James":[41]

Jacob
MaryJosephClopasanother Mary
JesusJames the Less
 
 		Joses
 
 		SimonJude
 
 

Development of the tradition

The Church Fathers in an 11th-century depiction from Kiev

From the 2nd century onward the developing emphasis on ascetism and celibacy as the superior form of Christian practice, together with an emphasis on the chastity of Mary, led to the idea that she had been a virgin not only before, but during and after, the birth of Christ.[42] There is no direct biblical basis for this idea,[43] which in its earliest assertion appears in the mid-2nd century Protoevangelium of James;[44] this depicts Mary as a life-long virgin, Joseph as an old man who marries her without physical desire, and the brothers of Jesus as Joseph's sons by an earlier marriage.[45]

By the 3rd century, the doctrine of the perpetual virginity of Mary had become well established, but the unequivocal scriptural references to the brethren of Jesus raised obvious problems.[46] The heretical antidicomarianites ("opponents of Mary") maintained that, when Joseph became Mary's husband, he was a widower with six children, and he had normal marital relations with Mary, but they later held Jesus was not born of these relations.[47] Bonosus was a bishop who in the late 4th century held Mary had other children after Jesus, for which the other bishops of his province condemned him.[48] Important orthodox theologians such as Hippolytus[49] (170–235), Eusebius (260/265–339/340) and Epiphanius (c. 310/320–403) defended the perpetual virginity of Mary. Eusebius and Epiphanius held the adelphoi were Joseph's children from a previous marriage. Epiphanius adds Joseph became the father of James and his three brothers (Joses, Simeon, Judah) and two sisters (a Salome and a Mary or a Salome and an Anna)[50] with James being the elder sibling. James and his siblings were not children of Mary but were Joseph's children from a previous marriage. Joseph's first wife died; many years later, at the age of eighty, "he took Mary (mother of Jesus)". According to Epiphanius the Scriptures call them "brothers of the Lord" to confound their opponents.[51][52] Origen (184–254) also wrote "according to the Gospel of Peter the brethren of Jesus were sons of Joseph by a former wife, whom he married before Mary".[53]

The History of Joseph the Carpenter, probably written in Egypt in the 5th century and heavily indebted to the Protoevangelium of James, depicts Joseph as an old widower with children from a previous marriage, thus clarifying the New Testament references to Jesus' brothers.[54]

According to the surviving fragments of the work Exposition of the Sayings of the Lord of the Apostolic Father Papias of Hierapolis, who lived circa 70–163 AD, "Mary the wife of Cleophas or Alphaeus" would be the mother of James the Just, Simon, Judas (identified as Jude the Apostle), and Joseph (Joses). Papias identifies this "Mary" as the sister of Mary, mother of Jesus, and thus as the maternal aunt of Jesus.[55] The Anglican theologian J.B. Lightfoot dismissed Papias' evidence as spurious.[56][57]

The Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew, which was probably written in the seventh century, states the brothers of Jesus were his cousins.[58]

Western Catholic and Eastern Christianity maintain that Mary was a perpetual virgin;[53] early Protestant leaders, including the Reformer Martin Luther,[59] and Reformed theologian Huldrych Zwingli,[60] also held this view, as did John Wesley, one of the founders of Methodism.[61] Eine Christliche Lehrtafel (A Christian Catechism), issued by Anabaptist leader Balthasar Hubmaier, teaches the perpetual virginity of the Virgin Mary too.[62] The Catholic Church, following Jerome, conclude that the adelphoi were Jesus' cousins, while Eastern Orthodox Church, following Eusebius and Epiphanius, argue they were Joseph's children from a previous marriage. Lutherans have accepted both views as being valid explanations of the doctrine of the perpetual virginity of Mary, while Anglicans and Methodists concur with the latter view.[63][6][5]

Other Christian denominations, such as some Baptist groups,[64] view the adelphoi as Jesus' half-brothers or do not specify,[63] since the accounts in the Gospels do not speak of Mary's relationship to them but only to Jesus.[65]

Absence of Jesus' brothers

There are some events in scripture where brothers or sisters of Jesus are not shown, e.g., when Jesus was lost in the Temple and during his crucifixion. Luke 2:41–51 reports the visit of Mary, Joseph, and Jesus to the Temple in Jerusalem when Jesus was 12 years old but does not mention any siblings. Robert Eisenman is of the belief Luke sought to minimise the importance of Jesus' family by whatever means possible, editing James and Jesus' brothers out of the Gospel record.[66] The Catholic apologist Karl Keating argues Mary and Joseph rushed without hesitation straight back to Jerusalem when they realized Jesus was lost, which they would surely have thought twice about doing if there were other children (Jesus' blood brothers or sisters) to look after.[67]

The Gospel of John records the sayings of Jesus on the cross, i.e., the pair of commands "Woman, behold your son!" and "Behold, thy mother!" (John 19:26–27), then states "from that hour the disciple took her unto his own home". Since the era of the Church Fathers this statement has been used to reason that after the death of Jesus there were no other biological children to look after Mary, and she had to be entrusted to the disciple.[68][69][70] Constantine Zalalas argues it would have been against Jewish custom for Jesus to give his mother to the care of the disciple if Mary had other living sons, because the eldest son would always take responsibility for his mother.[71] Karl Keating says, "It is hard to imagine why Jesus would have disregarded family ties and made this provision for his Mother if these four [James, Joseph/Joses, Simon, Jude] were also her sons".[67] Pope John Paul II also says the command "Behold your son!" was the entrustment of the disciple to Mary in order to fill the maternal gap left by the death of her only son on the cross.[72] Vincent Taylor points out difficulties in this interpretation of the text: it ignores both the fact that Jesus' brothers opposed his claims, and the position of honour of John, the beloved disciple.[73]

Descendants of Jesus' family

Eusebius of Caesarea, medieval Armenian manuscript from Isfahan, Persia

The early Christian historian Sextus Julius Africanus (died c. 240), in his "Genealogy of the Holy Gospels", referred to "relatives of our Lord according to the flesh" whom he called desposyni, meaning "from the Lord's family".[74] Of these individuals, only the 2nd century Bishop of Jerusalem Judah Kyriakos is historically attested by name.

See also

Notes

  1. ^ Greek singular noun adelphos, from a- ("same", equivalent to homo-) and delphys ("womb," equivalent to splanchna).
  2. ^ According to Hegesippus, Clopas is Joseph's brother, therefore Mary, wife of Clopas, would be Joseph's sister-in-law.

References

Citations

  1. ^ a b
    • Bateman 2014: "The Greek word here, adelphoi, literally means 'from the same womb,'"
    • Verbrugge 2017, p. 15: "one out of the [same] womb"
    • Curi 2020: "adelphoi, fratteli, fra coloro dunque che, letteralmente, provengono dallo stesso delphys, escono dallo stesso 'uttero'."
    • Segal 1999, p. 184: "For brothers related by blood Greek then develops a new term, adelphos, "of the same womb" (a-delphys), which denotes kinship through the mother.97"
    • Holman Bible Publishers et al. 2010: "Brothers (Gk adelphoi; vv. 9,14,17; 3:7; 4:1,10; 5:1,4,12,26) literally means 'from the same womb.'"
    • Dozier & Adams 1993, p. 4: "literally 'from the womb' and originally meant from the same womb."
    • Silver 1914, p. 272: "In the New Testament the Greek word ἀδελφοί (adelphoi) , rendered "brethren," is the plural form of ἀδελφός (adelphos) which means, literally, 'of the same womb, a brother, relative"
    • Levine 2022: "the Greek term adelphoi, literally 'brothers,'"
  2. ^ Cross & Livingstone 2005, p. 237.
  3. ^ a b Bauckham 2015, p. 8.
  4. ^ a b Cross & Livingstone 2005, p. 237-238.
  5. ^ a b Futrell, Rich (27 April 2013). "What are We to Make of the Perpetual Virginity of Mary?". Shepherd of the Hills Lutheran Church. Retrieved 18 September 2023.
  6. ^ a b Erasmus, Desiderius (1998). Disputatiuncula de Taedio, Pavore, Tristicia Iesu. University of Toronto Press. p. 187. ISBN 9780802043092. The Lutherans accepted the perpetual virginity of Mary, while rejecting the invocation of the saints.
  7. ^ Strauss 2009, p. 134.
  8. ^ a b c Edwards 2020, p. 159.
  9. ^ Shanks & Witherington 2003, p. 94.
  10. ^ Article "Frater" in Karl Ernst Georges, Oreste Badellino, Ferruccio Calonghi, Dizionario Latino-Italiano, Rosenberg & Sellier.
  11. ^ Bauckham 2015, p. 6,8.
  12. ^ Bauckham 2015, p. 7.
  13. ^ deSilva 2012, p. 34,37.
  14. ^ a b deSilva 2012, p. 37.
  15. ^ a b Boring 2012, p. 435.
  16. ^ Schreiner 2011, p. 110.
  17. ^ Painter 2001, p. 11.
  18. ^ a b c Hagner 2012, p. 780.
  19. ^ a b Cross & Livingstone 2005, p. 857.
  20. ^ deSilva 2018, p. 101.
  21. ^ Matera 2007, p. 66.
  22. ^ Matera 2007, p. 84.
  23. ^ Butz 2005, p. 67.
  24. ^ Bauckham 2015, p. 76.
  25. ^ Bauckham 2015, p. 39.
  26. ^ McKnight 2011, p. 13.
  27. ^ Lockett 2011, p. 9.
  28. ^ Boring 2012, p. 450.
  29. ^ Bauckham 2008, p. 72.
  30. ^ Frédéric Manns, Trenta domande (e Trenta Risposte) su Maria e la Nascita Di Gesù, Milano, Vita e Pensiero, 2007, p. 31.
  31. ^ a b c Painter 2001, p. 12.
  32. ^ a b Butz 2005, p. 27.
  33. ^ Rousseau, John J; Arav, Rami. "Jesus' Family Tree". www.pbs.org. PBS. Retrieved 3 February 2024.
  34. ^ Rousseau & Arav 1995, p. passim.
  35. ^ Butz 2005, p. 26-27.
  36. ^ Kelly 1975, p. 106.
  37. ^ Cross & Livingstone 2005, p. 238.
  38. ^ Butz 2005, p. 26.
  39. ^ a b c Bauckham 2015, p. 21.
  40. ^ Roberto Reggi, I fratelli di Gesù, EDB, Bologna, 2010.
  41. ^ Bauckham 2015, p. 22.
  42. ^ Bromiley 1995, p. 271.
  43. ^ Boisclair 2007, p. 1465.
  44. ^ Lohse 1966, p. 200.
  45. ^ Hurtado 2005, p. 448.
  46. ^ Foster 2008, p. 117.
  47. ^ Brackney 2012, p. 31.
  48. ^ Brackney 2012, p. 57.
  49. ^ of Rome, Hippolytus. Against Beron and Helix: Fragment VIII. Retrieved 18 February 2021.
  50. ^ College, St. Epiphanius of Cyprus; translated by Young Richard Kim, Calvin (2014). Ancoratus 60:1. Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America Press. p. 144. ISBN 978-0-8132-2591-3. Retrieved 22 September 2015.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  51. ^ Williams, translated by Frank (1994). The Panarion of Epiphanius of Salamis : Books II and III (Sects 47–80, De Fide). Leiden: E.J. Brill. p. 607. ISBN 9789004098985. Retrieved 18 September 2015.
  52. ^ Williams, translated by Frank (2013). The Panarion of Epiphanius of Salamis (Second, revised ed.). Leiden [u.a.]: Brill. p. 36. ISBN 9789004228412. Retrieved 18 September 2015.
  53. ^ a b Origen, Commentary on Matthew, Newadvent, § 17.
  54. ^ Ehrman & Plese 2011, p. 157.
  55. ^ of Hierapolis, Papias. "Fragment X". Exposition of the Sayings of the Lord. Peter Kirby. Retrieved 10 September 2015.
  56. ^ Lightfoot, J.B. (1865). "The Brethren of the Lord". Philo logos. Archived from the original on 18 June 2018. Retrieved 31 May 2016. The testimony of Papias is frequently quoted at the head of the patristic authorities, as favouring the view of Jerome… It is strange that able and intelligent critics should not have seen through a fabrication which is so manifestly spurious… [T]he passage was written by a mediaeval namesake of the Bishop of Hierapolis, Papias… who lived in the 11th century.
  57. ^ "Papias of Hierapolis". Text excavation. Archived from the original on 16 November 2015.
  58. ^ Kennedy, Jon; Schroedel, Jenny; Schroedel, John (2010), Jesus and Mary, Adams Media, ISBN 978-1-57215749-1[permanent dead link‍]
  59. ^ Martin Luther on Mary's Perpetual Virginity, archived from the original on 21 December 2008.
  60. ^ Zwingli, Ulrich (1905), "Eini Predigt von der ewig reinen Magd Maria", in Egli, Emil; Finsler, Georg; Zwingli-Verein (eds.), Huldreich Zwinglis sämtliche Werke (in German), vol. 1, Zürich: C. A. Schwetschke & Sohn, p. 385, retrieved 1 July 2008, I firmly believe that [Mary], according to the words of the gospel as a pure Virgin brought forth for us the Son of God and in childbirth and after childbirth forever remained a pure, intact Virgin
  61. ^ Wesley, John (1812), Benson, Joseph (ed.), The Works of the Rev. John Wesley, p. 112, I believe that He was made man, joining the human nature with the divine in one person; being conceived by the singular operation of the Holy Ghost, and born of the blessed Virgin Mary, who, as well after as before she brought Him forth, continued a pure and unspotted virgin.
  62. ^ Yarnell, Malcolm B. (2013). The Anabaptists and Contemporary Baptists. B&H Publishing. p. 130. ISBN 978-1-43368174-5. Question 53 of the Kinderfragen posed, "What do you believe about the Virgin Mary?" It parallesls questions 68 of the Lehrtafel, which solicited, "What do you believe regarding Our Lady? Both catechisms spoke of her perpetual virginity. The Kindergragen proclaimed "that she was pure before the birth, during the birth, and after the birth, a humble maiden," while the Lehrtafel declared that "she was a pure, chaste, and spotless Virgin before, during, and after the birth."
  63. ^ a b Longenecker, Dwight; Gustafson, David (2003). Mary. Gracewing Publishing. p. 64. ISBN 9780852445822.
  64. ^ Radano, John A. (30 April 2012). Celebrating a Century of Ecumenism: Exploring the Achievements of International Dialogue. Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing. p. 278. ISBN 9780802867056. Baptists do not find a scriptural basis for Catholic beliefs about her perpetual virginity, immaculate conception, and bodily assumption.
  65. ^ Witherington, Ben III, "Jesus' Extended Family", Bible Review, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 30–31, So James, according to this view, would be Jesus' younger half-brother.
  66. ^ Eisenman, Robert (2002), James, the Brother of Jesus, Watkins.
  67. ^ a b Keating, Karl (1988), Catholicism and Fundamentalism: The Attack on "Romanism" by "Bible Christians", Ignatius Press, p. 284, ISBN 978-0-89870-177-7
  68. ^ Arthur B. Calkins, "Our Lady's Perpetual Virginity," in Mark Miravalle, ed. (2008), Mariology: A Guide for Priests, Deacons, Seminarians, and Consecrated Persons ISBN 978-1-57918-355-4 pp. 308–309
  69. ^ Mark Miravalle, 1993, Introduction to Mary, Queenship Publishing ISBN 978-1-882972-06-7, pp. 62–63
  70. ^ Fundamentals of Catholicism, Kenneth Baker 1983 ISBN 0-89870-019-1 pp. 334–35
  71. ^ Zalalas, Constantine, Holy Theotokos: Apologetic Study.
  72. ^ L'Osservatore Romano, weekly ed. in English, 30 April 1997, p. 11 Article at EWTN Archived 24 September 2015 at the Wayback Machine
  73. ^ Taylor, Vincent (1952), The Gospel According to St Mark, London: MacMillan, p. 248
  74. ^ Rosik & Wojciechowska 2021, p. 108.

Bibliography

source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brothers_of_Jesus

    by LabLynx

    Website

    Related Posts